A leading lettings agent in the UK is urging politicians to rethink their stance on rent control policies. David Alexander, of DJ Alexander, which is Scotland’s largest lettings and estate agency, has expressed concerns over the current approach. He believes that the Housing Scotland Bill needs significant amendments to align with the realities of the housing market, particularly in the rental sector. His comments reflect a growing concern within the industry about the potential negative impacts of rent controls.
Alexander’s call to action comes in the wake of a report published by the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA). The report, released this week, delves into the effects of rent controls over the past six decades. It reviewed nearly 200 studies from different countries, examining the outcomes of rent regulation policies across various markets. The findings were clear: rent controls have historically failed to achieve their intended goals.
The IEA report highlights the consistent challenges rent controls have posed, such as reducing the availability of rental properties, lowering the quality of housing, and discouraging investment in the rental market. These unintended consequences have led to further strain on renters, contrary to the policies’ original objectives. The report’s conclusion that rent controls “have never worked” adds weight to the arguments presented by industry professionals like Alexander.
With mounting evidence against rent control measures, Alexander is urging politicians to reconsider their approach before implementing policies that could have long-term detrimental effects. He advocates for a more balanced and realistic solution that supports both landlords and tenants, ensuring a sustainable rental market in the future.
The Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) report found that rent controls often lead to higher prices, fewer available properties, and a decline in housing quality. As investment in housing decreases, the demand increases, driving rents higher for tenants.Â
The report also highlighted that lower returns on investment discourage landlords from making necessary repairs, further reducing the quality of housing. Instead of solving housing issues, rent controls can worsen the situation, creating additional challenges for both tenants and landlords.
According to the IEA, rent controls contribute to a reduction in the supply and quality of rental housing, discourage new construction, and decrease mobility among private tenants. These effects can lead to a misallocation of existing rental housing stock, aggravating the housing problem rather than improving it.
The report concludes that the negative impact of rent controls is widely acknowledged in economic research, marking a near consensus on the issue.
This report comes as Scottish council leaders express concerns about the financial burden of monitoring rents under the proposed Housing Scotland Bill. For example, Edinburgh City Council estimates that it would cost over £5.5 million to assess rents in the private rental sector, an expense the council says it cannot afford.
The Bill requires councils to gather data to determine if rent controls are necessary in specific areas. However, the Scottish government has not allocated any additional funding to support this effort, leaving councils to manage the financial strain on their own.
David Alexander, CEO of DJ Alexander Scotland, criticised the Bill, stating, “This is further proof that the Housing Scotland Bill, in its current form, is simply unworkable.” He echoed the findings of the IEA report, emphasising that rent controls historically fail to improve the situation for tenants, often making it worse.
The IEA report, which reviewed decades of research, argues that rent controls have consistently failed to address housing issues and, instead, have exacerbated them, further complicating the housing market for tenants across the country.
“They reduce investment, decrease the number of homes, and lower the quality of available properties, leading to increased demand and higher rents for tenants. The Scotland Housing Bill, if implemented as it stands, will only worsen an already dire situation.”
David Alexander also pointed out that the criticism from council leaders was expected, given their already strained finances. Adding more financial burdens to councils, which are struggling to stay afloat, was bound to face opposition.
He further noted that Scotland’s private rental sector saw a loss of 60,000 homes after rent controls were introduced in 2021. While the number has increased by just under 10,000 since then, the sector is still short by 50,000 properties. Restoring the housing stock to previous levels could help meet demand and stabilise rents.
Alexander expressed hope that the IEA report, along with the concerns raised by council leaders, would prompt the Scottish Government to reconsider the Housing Bill. He urged the government to either amend or scrap the Bill, arguing that in its current form, it is simply not workable.
Download NOW
4 Simple Steps To Becoming Wealthy Through Property