David Alexander, the managing director of DJ Alexander, one of the largest lettings and estate agencies in Scotland, is calling on politicians to reassess their stance on rent controls. Alexander argues that the current Housing Scotland Bill needs significant changes to better reflect the realities of the rental market. His call for reform highlights growing concerns within the industry about the effectiveness and impact of existing rent control measures.
This push for change comes in response to a recent report by the Institute for Economic Affairs (IEA). The IEA’s report examines nearly 200 studies conducted over the past 60 years on the effects of rent controls. According to the report, rent controls have consistently failed to deliver the benefits they were intended to provide, reinforcing the need for a re-evaluation of such policies.
Alexander’s comments underscore the broader debate surrounding rent controls and their impact on the housing market. As the largest lettings agency in Scotland, DJ Alexander’s stance is significant in the ongoing discussions about housing policy and market regulation. The report’s findings add weight to the argument that current rent control policies may not be the solution to housing affordability issues.
The IEA report concluded that rent controls have a negative impact on the housing market. It found that these controls lead to higher rents, a decrease in the number of available properties, and lower housing quality. As investment in housing declines, demand increases, pushing rents even higher.
The report also highlighted that reduced returns on investments can deter landlords from making necessary repairs, further diminishing the quality of rental properties. Rather than solving housing issues, rent controls tend to make them worse.
According to the IEA, “Rent controls decrease the supply and quality of rental housing, lower housing construction, hinder tenant mobility, and lead to a misallocation of rental housing. This is widely accepted in economic research.”
The report was released during a week when Scottish council leaders raised concerns about the costs of monitoring rents under the proposed Housing Scotland Bill. Edinburgh City Council, for instance, estimates that it would cost over £5.5 million to track rents in the private rental sector, a burden they claim they cannot bear.
The Bill requires councils to gather data to determine whether rent controls should be applied but does not provide additional government funding for this task.
David Alexander, CEO of DJ Alexander Scotland, criticised the Bill, stating, “This shows that the Housing Scotland Bill, as it stands, is unworkable. The IEA report confirms what we already know: rent controls don’t work and end up making things worse for tenants.”
David Alexander argues that the proposed Scotland Housing Bill, if enacted in its current form, will significantly worsen the existing housing crisis. He explains that rent controls have historically led to reduced investment in the rental market, resulting in fewer available homes and a decline in their quality. This situation creates higher demand for rental properties and, consequently, drives up rents for tenants. Alexander believes that the Bill will only exacerbate these problems rather than offering a viable solution.
He further emphasizes that the criticism from Scottish council leaders regarding the Bill was anticipated due to their already precarious financial positions. The Bill imposes additional costs on local authorities, which are already stretched thin. For instance, Edinburgh City Council has projected that it would cost over £5.5 million to monitor rent levels in their area—a cost they find unaffordable. Alexander argues that these added financial burdens will strain councils even further, making it difficult for them to manage and implement the proposed measures effectively.
Alexander highlights that the introduction of rent controls in 2021 led to a notable decrease in the number of private rented homes in Scotland, with a drop of 60,000 units. Although there has been a slight recovery, with the stock increasing by just under 10,000 units, the total number of available homes remains 50,000 below pre-control levels. He suggests that restoring the rental housing stock to its previous peak would help address the current demand and stabilize rent prices in the market.
In light of these issues, Alexander hopes that the findings from the IEA report, combined with the concerns expressed by council leaders, will prompt the Scottish Government to reconsider the Bill. He argues that the proposed legislation is unworkable and unaffordable, and its implementation will likely make Scotland’s housing emergency even worse. Alexander calls for a thorough review of the Bill to ensure that any proposed measures effectively address the housing crisis without exacerbating existing problems.
Alexander concludes by reiterating his belief that the Bill, as it stands, is not a practical solution to the housing issues facing Scotland. He stresses the need for a more effective approach that will improve housing conditions and affordability, rather than worsening the situation for tenants and local authorities alike.
Download NOW
4 Simple Steps To Becoming Wealthy Through Property