A recent study suggests a potential link between the number of Airbnb rentals in an area and the rate of robberies and violent crimes reported to the police. Researchers indicate that as the number of short-term rental listings rises, so too may certain types of criminal activity, drawing attention to how platforms like Airbnb might impact local communities.
This research, conducted by the University of Cambridge, focused on Airbnb listings and crime data from multiple London neighbourhoods between 2015 and 2018. By examining both the growth of short-term rentals and police crime statistics, the study aimed to assess whether higher numbers of Airbnb properties corresponded with shifts in reported crime levels.
The study’s co-author, Dr Charles Lanfear from Cambridge’s Institute of Criminology, notes that the team considered a variety of other possible factors that might influence crime rates. “We examined several other possible explanations, including changes in police patrol patterns, the presence of tourist hotspots, and even the timing of football matches,” he explains. This rigorous approach aimed to isolate any specific connection between Airbnb listings and crime rates.
These findings add to the ongoing conversation around the impact of short-term rentals on communities, raising questions for policymakers and local authorities. As Airbnb and similar platforms grow, understanding their broader social effects may be crucial in developing regulations that support community safety and address potential risks.
“Nothing changed the core finding that Airbnb rentals are linked to higher crime rates in London neighbourhoods. While Airbnb provides significant advantages for both tourists and hosts, such as convenience and financial rewards, there are potential social consequences associated with transforming large areas of the city into hotel-like environments with minimal regulation,” Lanfear explains. This statement highlights the ongoing debate about the balance between economic benefits and community safety.
London continues to be one of the most popular Airbnb markets in the world, drawing millions of visitors each year. During the period covered by the study, it was estimated that approximately 4.5 million guests stayed in various Airbnb properties throughout the city. This substantial number illustrates the platform’s widespread appeal and raises questions about its influence on local neighbourhood dynamics.
To conduct their research, Lanfear and his co-author, Professor David Kirk from the University of Pennsylvania, relied on extensive data sourced from AirDNA. This platform scrapes information from Airbnb listings to provide valuable insights, including key figures, trends, and approximate geolocations for the short-term letting market. By leveraging this comprehensive dataset, the researchers were able to analyse the relationship between Airbnb rentals and crime rates in detail.
The findings of this study contribute to a broader understanding of the implications of short-term rentals in urban settings. As the popularity of platforms like Airbnb continues to grow, it is essential for policymakers and local authorities to consider both the economic benefits and the potential risks to community safety. Balancing these factors will be crucial in developing regulations that protect neighbourhoods while still allowing for the advantages that short-term rentals can offer.
The researchers mapped AirDNA data over 13 calendar quarters, from January 2015 to March 2018, onto local areas that each had around two thousand residents. This mapping allowed them to analyse the impact of Airbnb listings on crime rates in specific neighbourhoods.
They compared this data with crime statistics from the UK Home Office and the Greater London Authority, focusing on six categories: robbery, burglary, theft, anti-social behaviour, any violence, and bodily harm. By examining these categories, the study aimed to determine the relationship between Airbnb rentals and various types of crime.
The analysis included all types of Airbnb rentals; however, the findings indicated that the link between active Airbnb listings and crime primarily involved entire properties being rented out, rather than spare or shared rooms. This distinction highlights the specific risks associated with whole-property rentals.
The association between active Airbnb rentals and crime was most pronounced for robbery and burglary, followed by theft and incidents of any violence. In contrast, the study found no significant link between Airbnb rentals and rates of anti-social behaviour or bodily harm, suggesting that the impact of short-term rentals may vary across different types of criminal activity.
On average, each additional Airbnb property in London was linked to a 2% increase in the robbery rate. The data also showed a 1% rise in thefts, a 0.9% increase in burglaries, and a 0.5% uptick in incidents of violence. These statistics indicate a concerning trend that suggests the proliferation of short-term rentals may have broader implications for community safety.
“While the potential criminogenic effect of each individual Airbnb rental is small, the cumulative impact of many rentals in a neighbourhood, or even tens of thousands spread across the city, could be significant,” Lanfear explains. This statement underscores the importance of considering not just the individual properties, but also the collective effect they may have on crime rates in different areas.
Lanfear elaborates that a single Airbnb rental can create multiple types of criminal opportunities. For example, these rentals can attract tourists who are often unfamiliar with the area, making them easy targets for criminals. Moreover, properties that are frequently vacant provide an easier opportunity for burglaries, as they are less likely to be monitored closely. Additionally, very temporary occupants might inadvertently cause criminal damage, either due to negligence or through behaviour associated with short-term stays. Offenders may also start to recognise patterns, returning to neighbourhoods with a high concentration of Airbnbs in search of unprotected targets.
In response to these growing concerns, Airbnb has taken various steps to prevent crime associated with its platform. These measures include conducting background checks on hosts and guests, as well as implementing requirements for longer bookings during times that are particularly popular for one-night parties, such as New Year’s Eve. Despite these efforts, the continued rise in crime linked to Airbnb rentals raises significant questions about the effectiveness of these measures. “The fact that we still observe an increase in crime despite Airbnb’s efforts to mitigate it highlights the seriousness of the situation,” co-author Kirk states.
These findings contribute to the ongoing discussion about the regulation of short-term rentals and the need for greater oversight. As cities continue to navigate the challenges posed by platforms like Airbnb, understanding the relationship between short-term rentals and crime will be crucial for developing policies that protect both residents and visitors.
Download NOW
4 Simple Steps To Becoming Wealthy Through Property